Gemstone Buyer's Guide: Certified Diamond Buyer's Guide
Certified Diamond Buyer's Guide

With statements of mathematical percentages and proportions, fluorescence and symmetry, diamond certificates can appear overwhelming to those unfamiliar with their concepts and terminology. The Hannoush Jewelers guide to certified diamonds will give you a thorough understanding of their terms, which will allow you to shop with total confidence!

The inherent value of a diamond certificate is that it is both an independent and absolute guarantee of a diamond’s quality – meaning you have total 100% peace of mind when spending thousands of dollars. This peace of mind derives from the fact that a diamond certificate is an extremely precise communication tool for all the complex information needed to accurately evaluate a large quality diamond.
The Inherent Value of a Diamond Certificate
Not included in the somewhat clichéd 4C’s information set, is the more explicit information that can make a large difference to the price of a diamond. On top of the 4C’s, a diamond’s depth, table, girdle, culet, polish, symmetry and fluorescence must also be considered.

While certification is not always necessary, especially on diamonds under 0.75 Carats or when you’re looking to pay well below market prices, a diamond certificate allows buyers and sellers, in totally different parts of the world, to accurately exchange precise information regarding these critical factors.

Unlike colored gemstones, diamonds are cut, shaped and proportioned to remarkably uniform ideals. In 1919, Marcel Tolkowsky published his theories regarding ideal diamond proportions. Tolkwosky’s proportions, which resulted in an optimum balance of brilliance and fire, have become the “industry standard” for larger diamonds. Today, larger diamonds (i.e. over 0.75 Carats) that fail to conform to Tolkwosky’s prescribed proportions can be comparatively less beautiful and are consequently less valued.



Depth Affects Beauty


Tolkwosky’s theories state that ideally a diamond’s depth should proportionately fall between 58% to 62% of its width or diameter. Measured from the culet to the crown, diamonds that possess these ideal proportions reflect light with the highest efficiency, resulting in the greatest beauty possible.

Diamonds that fail to conform to these ideals start to exhibit imperfections in their beauty. Diamonds that are cut with less than a 57% depth often possess “fish-eyes” – whereby an undesirable dark ring, that is actually a reflection of the diamonds girdle, is seen inside the pavilion. Conversely, those diamonds that possess a depth greater than 65% display what is sometimes called a “nail head” – whereby a dark reflection from the table is seen inside the pavilion.

Depth is always expressed as a percentage on a diamond certificate.


Table Sizes Affect The Brilliance Versus Fire Relationship

Often under appreciated, is the ability of the size of a diamond's table to affect the relational balance of brilliance and fire. The larger the table area that covers the crown of the diamond, the greater the amount of uninterrupted brilliance seen – but at the expense of the multicolored “fire” effect for which diamonds are so synonymous.

Conversely, the smaller the table area is, the larger the area of the angular crown. Large angular crown areas result in more refracted light, meaning we see more color and “fire”.

The left hand diamond possesses the most fire, the right hand diamond
possesses the most brilliance. As we move from left to right we see
brilliance increase, but at the expense of fiery twinkling color.


Over the past few years there has been a trend for smaller tables in order to give diamonds more fire. Currently, most diamond factories aim for about 53% - 60% of the crown of a round brilliant cut diamond being covered by the table. The table size is always expressed as a percentage on a diamond certificate, however please bear in mind there is no “optimum” percentage as a perfect balance of brilliance and fire is subjective and is very much down to personal taste.

Girdles – Not Too Thick, Not Too Thin

The girdle is an often un-faceted band around the outer most section of a diamond or gemstone, separating the crown from the pavilion. While sometimes polished, and stated so on a diamond certificate, the merits of faceted girdles are subjective and is again, very much down to personal taste.

More important is the thickness of a diamond’s girdle – the ideal is neither too thick nor too thin. Girdles that are very thin and knife-edge like afford a diamond little protection against knocks and abrasion. Conversely, girdles that are overly thick add weight but not size, making the diamond look too small for the stated carat weight.

Common grades for girdles in diamond certificate are “Extremely Thin”, “Very Thin”, “Thin”, “Medium”, “Slightly Thick”, “Thick”, “Very Thick” and “Extremely Thick”. Girdles of an inconstant thickness are expressed in a range such as “Medium To Slightly Thick”. Girdles that change in thickness around their circumference are viewed as a minor and somewhat trivial flaw.




Present At The Bottom Of this Diamond Is A Faceted Culet To Protect Against Abrasion.

To Culet Or Not To Culet? 

The culet is the sometimes-present facet on the bottom of a diamond’s pavilion. Often seen as a “keel” on oval and emerald cut diamonds, culets protect the sharp and narrow termination of a diamond’s pavilion from damage and abrasion.

In today’s diamond markets, culets have become less common as their presence can slightly detract from a diamond’s carat weight. Overly large culets are undesirable, as they tend to open up a “window” on an otherwise perfectly brilliant gem.

Polish – The Smoother The Better

The polish condition of a diamond should be good. Ranked on a diamond certificate as “Very Good”, “Good”, “Fair” and “Poor”, the quality of polish is affected by the presence of extra facets, naturals (i.e. remains of the original unpolished crystal surface), polishing lines, abrasions, surface pits and burn marks from polishing.

Symmetry – Matching Opposites

The cut of a diamond should exhibit good symmetry. Ideally, crown facets should be aligned straight in relation to facets on the pavilion, the girdle and to each other. Furthermore, facets should not be misshapen and the table should ideally be a regular octagon.

These ideals pale into insignificance when compared to serious symmetrical faults that can downgrade symmetry on a certificate. Serious faults include off-round girdles, wavy girdles, off-centre tables and off centre culets.

Grades for symmetry include “Ideal”, “Excellent”, “Very Good”, “Good”, “Fair” and “Poor”.


Fluorescence – Who Wants A Blue-White Diamond?

Have you ever heard of a “blue-white” diamond? They are diamonds that possess blue-white fluorescence. Once considered the crème de la crème, styles have now changed, with one of the prevalent beliefs of the diamond trade being that diamonds with fluorescence are less desirable.

Despite this modernist view on this blue-white effect, fluorescence can actually greatly benefit a diamond. Diamonds with tinted color grades of H to M actually benefit from a moderate amount of fluorescence, as the effect makes the diamond look whiter.

Some people actively admire this fluorescence and appreciate its subtle blue-white effect. Whatever your opinion on the merits of blue-white fluorescence, many diamonds possess this property and they often represent exceptionally good value.

If you take all of the above into account when reviewing a diamond certificate, you’ll be well on your way to buying quality diamonds with absolute confidence. However, please remember that certification is not always necessary, especially on diamonds under 0.75 Carats or when you’re looking to pay well below market prices.

 

  © Hannoush Jewelers 2008